After the clip was shown, two questions were asked of the audience, comprised of members of the Leo A. Deegan Inn of Court: “Has anyone experienced this type of bias before, either toward themselves, or toward someone they know” and “If so, briefly describe what happened.” The audience members’ answers were displayed on the screen with the help of a polling app.
It was surprising to see that many of the audience members had experienced similar bias in their legal profession, primarily female attorneys who had been asked if they planned to have children and those who had been passed up for a partnership opportunity due to being pregnant. Some attorneys had been asked if they were the court reporter when they walked into a deposition or court room.
Special Guest Presenter Virginia Blumenthal, a notable criminal defense attorney and owner of the first female-led law firm in Riverside County, shared her similar struggles at gaining employment as an attorney in the Inland Empire after graduating from law school in 1975, a mere 16 years after Ruth Bader Ginsburg graduated. In those 16 years, times had not changed. Additional information about Ms. Blumenthal can be found in the July/August 2020 issue of Riverside Lawyer, a publication of the Riverside County Bar Association. The portion of the magazine containing only Ms. Blumenthal’s article “My Journey Through the Glass Ceiling” can be found here.
Ms. Blumenthal answered at least ten questions from the audience, ranging from “What advice do you have for a female attorney who has encountered gender discrimination from the bench or opposing counsel?” to “Who is your inspiration?” Each of her responses was thoughtful and well received by the members.
Barrister Joshlynn Pulliam gave a brief synopsis of the appellate case, Charles E. Moritz v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 469 F. 2d 466 (1972). The team showed a film clip where Professor Ruth Bader Ginsburg presented rebuttal argument in that case, heard by the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.